Finding Integer Points on a Circle
I got interested in the following problem: Given a positive integer $n$,
$$ x^2 + y^2 = n $$
defines a circle on the plane. The question is: are there integer points (i.e. points whose $x$-and-$y$ coordinates both are integers) lying on this circle?
This problem seems difficult to solve analytically, so I wrote the following R code to explore:
chk_sq <- function(x)
{floor(sqrt(x))^2 == x
}
find_integer_points <- function(n)
{r <- floor(sqrt(n))
x <- 0:r
y_sq <- n - x^2
the_index <- which(chk_sq(y_sq))
the_x <- x[the_index]
if(length(the_x) == 0) {
return(sprintf("There are no integer points on x^2+y^2=%d!", n))}
the_y <- floor(sqrt(y_sq[the_index]))
df <- data.frame(x = the_x,
y = the_y)
return(df)
}
(re <- find_integer_points(2024))
## [1] "There are no integer points on x^2+y^2=2024!"
(re <- find_integer_points(2025))
## x y
## 1 0 45
## 2 27 36
## 3 36 27
## 4 45 0
(re <- find_integer_points(2026))
## x y
## 1 1 45
## 2 45 1
(re <- find_integer_points(2027))
## [1] "There are no integer points on x^2+y^2=2027!"
Afterward, I searched online and found two references:
-
Ref 1 (https://faculty.etsu.edu/gardnerr/3120/notes-Dudley/Dudley-Section-18.pdf)
-
Ref 2 (https://faculty.etsu.edu/gardnerr/3120/Beamer-Dudley/Proofs-Dudley-18-print.pdf)
The main result in both references is the following:
Theorem 18.1. Integer $n$ cannot be written as the sum of two squares if and only if the prime-power decomposition of $n$ contains a prime congruent to 3 (mod 4) to an odd power.